DEBORAH HENSON-CONANT WEBSITE - A MUSICIAN'S DIARY (9/25/01)
TO DIARY & ESSAY TABLE OF CONTENTS
HOME |CATALOG | ORDERS | FAQ | PUBLICITY | TOUR SCHEDULE | DHC'S DIARY

THE PLASTIC KNIFE CUTS DEEP ©2001 Deborah Henson-Conant

On September 13th, Boston Globe arts reviewer Ed Siegel called me to ask a question he was asking artists all over Boston: what is the role of art in our present crisis? In that conversation I struggled to answer the question, rambling, stuttering and wishing I had an answer. From my ramblings, Ed was able to distill one idea: that art can help to humanize us in the midst of a situation that seems inhuman.

As I often find in good interviews, the questions made me start looking at my own life and work more closely.

I had just come home from touring Europe for the summer and had no concerts in the U.S. until Sept. 22, when I’d planned to fly to Michigan for a concert in the small town of Greenville, just outside Grand Rapids. Boston was the last airport in the U.S. to open and even three days before my flight to Greenville, I wasn’t sure whether I’d be driving a rental car to Michigan, or whether my flight would actually take off.

After my flight time was changed several times by the airlines, I finally got to the airport on the 20th. Once through the long baggage line, I found myself feeling very, very sad in the airport, which seemed so big and empty, even though I was in the smallest terminal. I wasn’t scared to get on the plane, I just felt horribly sad. Life in Boston itself hadn’t seemed so different since the 11th, which was in itself, disturbing. But here the difference was profound. The place was empty.

On the plane, Midwest, the attendants and pilots did their best to act normal. At lunch time, they brought our meals. The silverware was wrapped in a linen napkin (no, I wasn’t in first class, Midwest is just a classy airline). I opened the napkin and saw: a stainless steel fork, a stainless steel spoon ... and a plastic knife.

That was the moment reality hit me. All the images, the fear and the unutterable sadness flooded down on me and I burst into tears, and couldn’t stop crying. The sense of unreality I’d felt for the past 9 days broke and the tragedy hit me viscerally. For once, I knew it was OK to cry in public, that no-one would come along nervously and say, “What’s wrong?” Everyone knew what was wrong, and I supposed that the flight attendants had seen many people in tears in the last few days. One of them came by with a pack of kleenex and pressed it into my hand, then left me alone to cry.

I stayed in Grand Rapids for two nights, meeting with the Ballet company and the Symphony and dining with friends. The night before my concert in Greenville, there was a big benefit concert on TV. Famous stars and musicians were raising money for the victims of the attacks. I felt like my own meager attempts to help were meaningless: the Red Cross didn’t need more blood, and the people stranded at Boston Logan airport who we’d offered to put up in our home had apparently found other lodging. We lit candles and listened for hours to the radio feeling helpless, meaningless and ineffectual. Now I felt even more useless: there was no way I could help in the kind of big way these musicians on TV were helping and I felt like a failure as an artist, a meaningless drop in an infinitesimal bucket.

On the way to my concert, I thought that I couldn’t be the only one feeling that way. Probably most of the people in the little town of Greenville felt just as ineffectual and wanted to help just as much as I did. I decided I could be a conduit for help by giving 50% of the money from my CD sales that night to the American Red Cross. But I was embarrassed about how to tell the audience that and uncertain how to do it practically. I decided I simply had to overcome my embarrassment, because I really needed to help -- and I would work out the practicals later. Otherwise I was making myself ever more a victim of the violence.

When I got to Greenville, I discovered that the entire town was planning a big fundraising bazaar for the coming Thursday, to benefit the American Red Cross, and I realized that the money from my CDs could be part of that. I could simply give it to the mayor (who was at my concert) at the end of the night. I didn’t have to be embarrassed by my desperation to be helpful – this whole TOWN desperately wanted to be helpful and I could just be part of that.
I started my show the way I often do: in darkness, with the song “Love is on Your Side.” I hadn’t performed or thought of performing since Sept. 11th, and as I started I heard myself singing as though from far away:

Life is never gonna break you,
No matter how hard you fall,
Life is never gonna break you,
Cause that’s not like life at all.

No matter how long you waited,
No matter how hard you tried,
Love is gonna take you, gonna wake you, gonna shake you,
Honey love is on your side.

I felt I had never heard those words before and that I was singing to myself, and I felt a surge of energy I hadn’t expected. I realized, shocked, that for 11 days, from September 11th until I started that song, I had been dead, emotionally. I hadn’t even known it. I also hadn’t known that it would be my own singing that would bring me back to life, that could make me human. When I’d spoken to Ed Siegel at the Boston Globe about the job of the artist in a crisis, I was thinking of the role the artist plays in helping the AUDIENCE connect with their emotions, in how the artist is a conduit for the AUDIENCE’s connection with their own humanity. I hadn’t realized that the audience helps the ARTIST connect with their humanity - that the audience makes a place for the artist to express their emotions. I hadn’t realized that my expression is my own salvation.
So, please, no matter what your artform, no matter what you think is your level of expertise -- get out there - play, sing, make a joyful noise, or a sad noise, or an angry noise, but make YOUR noise. As artists, as musicians, each one of us is an ambassador for humanity. You can bring yourself back to life and you can help others come back to life. Truly, love IS on our side.
Deborah Henson-Conant (Sept. 25, 2001)